Senior Editor Votes: Difference between revisions
Ralf.haring (talk | contribs) (New page: 2008 February 12 - The vote was: "Should Anthology be included on the official list of genres?" Vote: 1 - Yes (Mark) 7 - No (Jamal, Don, Ralf, Peter, Lou, Matthias, Ramon) 1 - Abstain (Ra...) |
Ralf.haring (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
2008 February 12 - | ==2008 February 12 - anthology genre== | ||
Should Anthology be included on the official list of genres? | |||
Vote: | Vote: | ||
1 | 1 Yes (Mark) | ||
7 | 7 No (Jamal, Don, Ralf, Peter, Lou, Matthias, Ramon) | ||
1 | 1 Abstain (Ray) | ||
Result: Anthology should not be included as an addition to the genre list. | Result: '''Anthology should not be included as an addition to the genre list.''' | ||
==2008 February 19 - kung-fu genre== | |||
Should Kung-Fu be replaced with Martial Arts on the official list of genres as stated above? | |||
Vote: | |||
7 Yes (Ramon, Peter, Lou, Ralf, Matthias, Jamal, Mark) | |||
0 No | |||
2 Abstain (Ray, Donald) | |||
Result: '''Kung-Fu should be replaced with Martial Arts on the official list of genres.''' | |||
==2008 April 5 - cover editor== | |||
The role of cover editor would include: | |||
1) Monitor the daily cover upload page and enforce the standards that are described. | |||
2) Maintain those standards, clarifying and adding to them as appropriate. | |||
3) Maintain a page noting the most current upload standards being enforced. [currently most likely on the editor wiki, but ideally on the site itself] | |||
4) If there is a dispute about whether or not a cover is appropriate, the cover editor has final say. | |||
Result: '''No result. Mark leaves senior editor group.''' | |||
==2008 April 11 - sequence number format== | |||
http://maelstrom.walton.uark.edu/wiki/Sequence_Number | |||
Vote: | |||
7 Yes (Peter, Lou, Ray, Don, Ramon, Ralf, Jamal) | |||
0 No | |||
1 Abstain (Matthias) | |||
Result: '''http://maelstrom.walton.uark.edu/wiki/Sequence_Number''' | |||
Revision as of 00:37, 10 September 2008
2008 February 12 - anthology genre
Should Anthology be included on the official list of genres?
Vote: 1 Yes (Mark) 7 No (Jamal, Don, Ralf, Peter, Lou, Matthias, Ramon) 1 Abstain (Ray)
Result: Anthology should not be included as an addition to the genre list.
2008 February 19 - kung-fu genre
Should Kung-Fu be replaced with Martial Arts on the official list of genres as stated above?
Vote: 7 Yes (Ramon, Peter, Lou, Ralf, Matthias, Jamal, Mark) 0 No 2 Abstain (Ray, Donald)
Result: Kung-Fu should be replaced with Martial Arts on the official list of genres.
2008 April 5 - cover editor
The role of cover editor would include:
1) Monitor the daily cover upload page and enforce the standards that are described.
2) Maintain those standards, clarifying and adding to them as appropriate.
3) Maintain a page noting the most current upload standards being enforced. [currently most likely on the editor wiki, but ideally on the site itself]
4) If there is a dispute about whether or not a cover is appropriate, the cover editor has final say.
Result: No result. Mark leaves senior editor group.
2008 April 11 - sequence number format
http://maelstrom.walton.uark.edu/wiki/Sequence_Number
Vote: 7 Yes (Peter, Lou, Ray, Don, Ramon, Ralf, Jamal) 0 No 1 Abstain (Matthias)
Result: http://maelstrom.walton.uark.edu/wiki/Sequence_Number